Lumpkin County Sheriffs Office Solves 2001 Homicide of Herman Wilder

PRESS RELEASE – The Lumpkin County Sheriffs Office announces that the 2001 homicide of Herman Wilder has been officially solved through DNA. The investigation has determined that Carroll Dean Burrell (Rabun County), now deceased, was responsible for Wilder’s death on May 25, 2001, at Golden Hills Apartments in Dahlonega.

On the night of the incident, deputies responded to a report of a violent assault and located Wilder outside his apartment suffering from severe injuries. Evidence collected at the scene included a wooden stake believed to be the murder weapon and a blue baseball cap. Despite extensive investigative efforts at the time, a suspect was identified but later dismissed, and the DNA profile recovered from the scene did not match the original suspect or any known offender in CODIS.

In 2023, investigators reopened the case and submitted the retained DNA evidence for new evaluations and processing. Working in partnership with the Georgia Bureau of Investigation and other local agencies, investigators obtained voluntary DNA samples from leads established in the investigation. The resulting comparisons conclusively identified Carroll Dean Burrell (Rabun County), as the source of the DNA found on the murder

weapon.

Carroll Dean Burrell (Rabun County), who was 41 years old at the time of the crime,

had a documented history of mental health issues and was known to have exhibited delusional and violent behavior. Burrell is now deceased, and after discussion with the District Attorney the case will be exceptionally cleared in accordance with Georgia law.

Sheriff Jarrard expressed appreciation for the perseverance of investigators and the

advancements in forensic technology that made this resolution possible.

“This case represents over two decades of determination and teamwork,” said Sheriff Jarrard. “Through modern forensic science and the dedication of our investigators, we have finally identified the person responsible and can provide closure to the Wilder family.”

The Lumpkin County Sheriffs Office extends gratitude to the Georgia Bureau of Investigation, and all other partner agencies whose collaboration helped bring resolution to this long standing case.